SIGI Selective Insurance Group Earnings and EPS analysis

Relative Growth: Rel. Growth: 92

Relative Strength: Rel. Strength: 64

Relative Valuation: Rel. Valuation: 93

Relative Profitability: Rel. Profitability: 68

EPS in 2026 (TTM): $7.36

Last Report Period Date: Mar 31, 2026

As of June 2026, according to Selective Insurance Group's latest financial report, the company's current EPS (TTM) is $7.36. Selective Insurance Group's EPS for 2025 came in at $7.54, marking an increase from $3.25 in 2024. Selective Insurance Group's earnings per share for the quarterly report ending on Mar 31, 2026 was $1.59.

SIGI earnings history

Historical annual and quarterly earnings per share (EPS) data for Selective Insurance Group

EPS (TTM)

$7.36

EPS Growth YoY (Quarterly)

-10.2%

EPS (Quarterly)

$1.59

EPS Growth (Quarterly)

-37.2%

The annual EPS in 2025 was $7.54, an increase of 132% from $3.25 in 2024. The quarterly EPS for the period ending Mar 31, 2026, was $1.59, marking a 10.2% decrease from the same quarter last year. SIGI's TTM EPS stands at $7.36 as of March 2026. Selective Insurance Group's EPS for 2024 stood at $3.25, a 44.6% decrease from 2023.

SIGI earnings chart

SIGI EPS growth history

Earnings per share growth rates over time

EPS Growth YoY (Quarterly)

-10.2%

EPS growth YoY

132%

EPS growth 3Y avg

28.3%

EPS growth 5Y avg

12.8%

Over the last 12 months, Selective Insurance Group has registered an EPS growth of -10.2% (YoY, quarterly). Looking at a longer timeframe, the company recorded an average EPS growth rate of 28.3% per year over the past 3 years. Over the last 5 years, the company had an average EPS growth rate of 12.8%. A 10-year view shows that SIGI has seen an average EPS growth of 10% per year.

SIGI Earnings Waterfall

Breakdown of revenue, profit and net income for Selective Insurance Group

SIGI Earnings vs Peers

What are the earnings of SIGI compared to its peers

Stock name	Price to Earnings	EPS grwoth 1Y	EPS grwoth 3Y	EPS grwoth 5Y
HIG Hartford Financial Services Group Inc	9.11	28.5%	34.6%	23%
TRV Travelers Companies Inc	9.31	27.9%	32.7%	21.4%
CINF Cincinnati Financial Corp	9.95	4.6%	N/A	15.2%
THG Hanover Insurance Group Inc	10.26	56.1%	78.4%	14.2%
PGR Progressive Corp	10.93	33.5%	153.1%	14.7%
SIGI Selective Insurance Group Inc	12.83	132%	28.3%	12.8%
MKL Markel Corp	13.61	-15%	N/A	25%
WRB Berkley W R Corp	14.55	2.1%	10.4%	28.9%
ERIE Erie Indemnity Co	18.02	-6.8%	23.3%	13.8%
FUL Fuller H B Co	21.62	17.3%	-6.2%	3.2%

All data is based on quarterly TTM periods, unless otherwise specified.